Restorative Justice
Approaches to Obstetric Violence

This section presents a selection of texts written by members of the IPOV – Respectful Care project team, exploring how restorative justice can serve as an ethical and transformative approach to address obstetric violence.

Within the IPOV framework, restorative justice is not understood as a replacement for legal accountability, but as a complementary path toward recognition, reparation, and collective learning. The writings gathered here examine its institutional, emotional, and symbolic dimensions—emphasizing the need for safe spaces, adequate timing, and professional training to ensure meaningful and non-punitive forms of repair.

Drawing on interdisciplinary research and field experiences, these reflections highlight how restorative justice opens new possibilities for dialogue between women, families, and healthcare teams, helping rebuild trust and promote a culture of care grounded in empathy, ethics, and respect.

Each text contributes to an evolving conversation on how healthcare systems can move beyond punitive paradigms toward more humanized, participatory, and reparative models of perinatal care.

Coordinators of this section

Serena Brigidi

U. Rovira i Virgili

Field of Knowledge: U(AFTS) | Degrees: PhD from Universitat Rovira i Virgili | Research Group: Social Anthropology Group 

Silvina García

ACADP Asociación Civil Argentina de Puericultura

Birth and Labour Rights. Coordinator of the Women's Health Rights Committee at the Ministry of Health.

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Research Executive Agency (REA). Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.

Disclaimer

Our selection of texts written by IPOV professionals:

This section brings together a selection of texts written by professionals participating in the IPOV – Respectful Care project, focusing on restorative justice approaches to obstetric violence.

Through interdisciplinary perspectives and experiences across different regional contexts, these writings explore how restorative frameworks can help acknowledge harm, support healing, rebuild trust, and foster accountability in maternity care.

Rather than presenting restorative justice as a single model, the authors invite readers to see it as a set of context-sensitive practices and principles — centered on the needs and voices of those affected, dialogue where appropriate, and the transformation of relationships and institutions to prevent further harm and strengthen respectful, rights-based care.

Obstetric violence and the judicialisation of maternal health rights violations in Mexico

In this post, members of the Obstetric Violence Reading Group reflect on Paola Sesia’s chapter titled “Naming, framing and shaming through obstetric violence: A critical approach to judicialisation of maternal health rights violations in Mexico” in Gamlin, J et al (eds) Critical Medical Anthropology: Perspectives in and from Latin America (2020) 222-247.
IPOV Respectful Care
diciembre 9, 2025

Salud mental perinatal y violencia obstétrica: tensiones, impactos y horizontes reparadores

Obstetric violence and perinatal mental health are intertwined phenomena that have gained visibility within interdisciplinary research on human rights, gender and public health. Within the IPOV project (International Platform on Obstetric Violence), which seeks to develop global conceptual frameworks and strategies to address obstetric violence, it is crucial to explore how these experiences affect the psychological well-being of women, pregnant people, their babies and families, as well as the possible practices of reparation.
IPOV Respectful Care
noviembre 15, 2025

Restorative Justice in Childbirth

Restorative justice is an approach to justice focused on repairing the harm caused to the victim through the active participation of both the victim and the responsible party, in contrast to the traditional punitive paradigm.
IPOV Respectful Care
octubre 28, 2025

Justicia restaurativa como estrategia transformadora frente a la violencia obstétrica

Obstetric violence is a specific form of gender-based violence that occurs within both public and private healthcare systems and violates the rights of women and their newborns. Restorative justice, conceived as a formative rather than punitive process, can become a transformative tool to repair harm and prevent further violations. This essay presents a critical analysis of restorative justice in cases of obstetric violence, highlighting the importance of time, safe spaces, and health team training to ensure ethical and meaningful processes of reparation.
María Hidalgo Rudilla
julio 14, 2025